Post by Garfield (RadioShack, commish) on Jan 25, 2020 6:48:57 GMT 1
Rules:
Once you feel your brainstorming process is complete*, you have to decide whether (A) you'd run your league yourself, or (B) you'd like to me to run it.
* - Don't make the mistake of thinking your idea isn't popular simply because there is little feedback in the brainstorming thread. You'll only receive feedback once you officially propose it here. The brainstorming thread is simply for arguing about the potential rules, so if they are clear enough, nobody will comment.
(A) I'll create the forum for you if 6+ people sign up, and then it's all in your hands. See Cyclopaths.
(B) I might want to meddle with your rules heavily, and I'd have to believe in the game in the first place.
On the plus side, I have been designing games my entire life, and I already know how the sheet works.
If you choose (A), just post the official proposal below, but please stick to the proposed format.
If you choose (B), please PM me.
You'll have until Jan 29 to polish your single post below by editing it. No other posts here please. All questions & comments to be posted in the brainstorming thread.
Timing:
Jan 25-29 - posting official proposals below
Jan 30-31 - people voting on all proposals in a single post
(However, don't feel obliged to just yes/no, feel free to be creative:
e.g. you can rank your interest 1-10 and/or specify you like 5 games but don't wish to add more than 2 this season etc.)
Feb 1 - I'll create a separate forum for every game where 6+ people signed up
Feb 2 - let's rock'n'roll
Format:
Name: (with an abbreviation different from existing games QF CR RC FYC WS LBB )
Synopsis:
Difficulty: (1-10 compared to our existing games, as perceived by you)
Originality: (1-10)
Tactics: (1-10)
In-season activity: (1-10)
The exact wording of the rules: ... (no half-baked ideas please)
Once you feel your brainstorming process is complete*, you have to decide whether (A) you'd run your league yourself, or (B) you'd like to me to run it.
* - Don't make the mistake of thinking your idea isn't popular simply because there is little feedback in the brainstorming thread. You'll only receive feedback once you officially propose it here. The brainstorming thread is simply for arguing about the potential rules, so if they are clear enough, nobody will comment.
(A) I'll create the forum for you if 6+ people sign up, and then it's all in your hands. See Cyclopaths.
(B) I might want to meddle with your rules heavily, and I'd have to believe in the game in the first place.
On the plus side, I have been designing games my entire life, and I already know how the sheet works.
If you choose (A), just post the official proposal below, but please stick to the proposed format.
If you choose (B), please PM me.
You'll have until Jan 29 to polish your single post below by editing it. No other posts here please. All questions & comments to be posted in the brainstorming thread.
Timing:
Jan 25-29 - posting official proposals below
Jan 30-31 - people voting on all proposals in a single post
(However, don't feel obliged to just yes/no, feel free to be creative:
e.g. you can rank your interest 1-10 and/or specify you like 5 games but don't wish to add more than 2 this season etc.)
Feb 1 - I'll create a separate forum for every game where 6+ people signed up
Feb 2 - let's rock'n'roll
Format:
Name: (with an abbreviation different from existing games QF CR RC FYC WS LBB )
Synopsis:
Difficulty: (1-10 compared to our existing games, as perceived by you)
Originality: (1-10)
Tactics: (1-10)
In-season activity: (1-10)
The exact wording of the rules: ... (no half-baked ideas please)